10. 12. 2025
- Josef Brynda
Financial markets are anxiously awaiting the culmination of the Federal Open Market Committee’s (FOMC) December meeting, which is taking place in an exceptionally complex environment. Although investors almost unanimously agree that the central bank will cut interest rates by a quarter of a percentage point to a range of 3.50–3.75%, the path to this decision is paved with uncertainty. According to futures market data, the probability of such a move is nearly 90%, which would mark the third cut in a row and bring borrowing costs to their lowest level since September 2022. Analysts warn, however, that despite this consensus, this will not be a routine meeting but rather a clash of differing views on whether the economy needs further support or whether there is a risk of reigniting inflation.
One of the biggest challenges facing Chair Jerome Powell and his colleagues is the critical lack of up-to-date information. As a result of the recent record-long 43-day government shutdown, the Fed is operating in what has been called a “data fog.” Key reports on November unemployment and inflation were postponed until mid-December, after today’s decision. Central bankers therefore must rely on outdated or incomplete data, such as yesterday’s JOLTS report. It showed that the number of job openings in October rose slightly to 7.67 million, indicating resilience in the labor market, but a growing number of layoffs suggests cracks forming beneath the surface.
This uncertainty is deepening an already pronounced divide within the committee itself. Today’s vote is expected to produce an unusually high number of dissenting opinions, possibly the most in a decade. On one side stand “hawks” like Jeffrey Schmid, who would prefer to keep rates unchanged due to inflation concerns. On the opposite end is Stephen Miran, a new board member appointed by President Trump, who has publicly called for a more aggressive 50-basis-point cut, arguing that current policy is stifling the economy. This internal conflict puts Powell in a difficult position, as he will have to defend a compromise on the press conference and likely adopt a “hawkish cut” tone, easing policy while warning that further moves are not guaranteed.
The situation is further complicated by unprecedented political pressure from the White House. President Trump has repeatedly criticized Powell for cutting rates too slowly and recently even hinted at removing Governor Lisa Cook, raising fears about the institution’s independence. Adding to this mix are worries about fiscal expansion and new tariffs that could reignite inflation in 2026. For this reason, despite the expected rate cut. 10-year Treasury yields are not falling but instead remain near 4.19%, reflecting investor nerves about the long-term outlook for U.S. debt and inflation.
For investors, the key this afternoon will be not only the decision itself, but also the release of the new interest-rate outlook for 2026, known as the “dot plot.” While markets are currently betting that the Fed will cut rates four times next year, policymakers’ own projections may be far more cautious, pointing to only two cuts. If Powell’s comments or the charts confirm a more restrained approach, it could cool hopes for a traditional Santa Claus rally. The outcome of today’s meeting will determine whether financial markets end 2025 with new highs or with a dose of reality.
Scenario A: Hawkish Cut (60%)
The Fed cuts rates by 25 bps, but the accompanying communication is cautious to hawkish. There may be 2–3 dissenting votes. The 2026 Dot Plot will show only two cuts. Powell will emphasize data uncertainty and avoid committing to another move in January. Markets may react with mild volatility, yields stay elevated, the dollar strengthens, and equities see a muted response.
Scenario B: Dovish Consensus (25%)
The Fed also cuts by 25 bps, but with little dissent. The 2026 projections will show three to four cuts. Powell will express confidence in declining inflation and highlight concerns about a weakening labor market. Markets would react positively, equities rally (especially small caps and tech), yields fall, the dollar weakens, and gold and crypto move higher.
Scenario C: Shock (15%)
The Fed either holds rates unchanged or surprises with a 50 bps cut. A “hold” would trigger a sharp selloff as markets fear a policy mistake. A 50 bps cut would spark short-term euphoria, quickly replaced by concern that the Fed may be reacting to hidden economic weakness.